Bitter water is in Gansu Province Lanzhou, there is the oldest rose to produce base here, attar majority of China originates in here.

苦水在甘肃兰州，这儿有中国最大的玫瑰生产基地，中国的玫瑰油绝大部分产于这里。

These traditions come from Farid ud din Attar a later sufi saint and poet, who used earlier sources. Rabia herself though has not left any written works.

虽然拉比尔自己没有留下任何文字作品，但是这些来自里德阿塔尔，以及后来成为圣徒和诗人的苏菲的传统，都使用了更早的惯例。